The film Contagion deals with a woman (Beth), who returns from a trip from Hong Kong and then she
and several others from the area she visited become sick and die within a
period of three days. This sickness begins as an outbreak and then grows
exponentially around the world. The Centers For Disease Control and
Prevention work arduously to find replicate it and create a vaccine for the
disease, but it mutates quickly and takes a long time to finally make a
successful vaccine. Meanwhile, there is panic around the U.S. due to the
negative media and large death toll. I thought the movie was, in all honesty,
quite scary. It emphasized on that
public health tells us to do – wash hands, don’t sneeze on your hands, don’t
touch your face too much – and the like. Also, it also showed the many
complicated processes that go in to trying to attack such a serious problem as
a pandemic. This week in lab we learned how to properly state a “problem
definition” and then work from there to solve the specifics on this problem. In
the movie, however, there were so many factors to worry about and try to track
since it was such a large population of people and the disease was spreading
extremely rapidly while the issues of rising death tolls, panic in reaction to
social media and harder and harder ethical decisions continued to occur. It
made me think of how hard it is to address and try to solve such an issue is
with all the factors surrounding the problem going on around it. This was my
first time seeing this movie.
There were several public health concepts in the film. Initially
there was an outbreak with Beth when she returned and started spreading the
disease, which is a sudden and violent start of something unwelcome, in this
case being the infection. Following that, when more cases were heard about the
same symptoms and similar death, it was made apparent that this was a threat to
others and an outbreak investigation began in which the members of the CDC
would form a hypothesis for what could be happening, test or try to find the
cause of the outbreak, and then take appropriate measures as needed. Once there
were clear indications of who had the infection and who didn't, many people
were put in isolation, either to avoid those who had the disease or not infect
those who did not have it. We saw this with Mitch and his daughter as they separated themselves from others as much as possible avoiding physical contact.
Lastly, large areas of affected people were quarantined, meaning placed
together away from others without the infection, so that the infection would be
concentrated in one area and can also be triaged and treated with ease. The
area in which Mitch and his daughter lived was quarantined and blocked off; no
one was allowed to leave or enter this area since it was immensely infected.
One of the main points which stood out to me from chapter 29
was expect the unexpected. Be ready to respond to unanticipated problems.
Obviously this infection was an unanticipated problem. However, one of the
actions that the public health agencies could have taken for better preparation
was to pay more attention to the infection as the outbreak started. In 2009 in
the United States there was an outbreak of swine flu, otherwise known as H1N1. Fortunately, the
case was not as critical as anticipated; that was because the infection was
isolated quickly. The infection in Contagion, however, was not isolated quickly
and therefore spread all over the country. The book also says that warnings
should be issued and evacuations ordered by the appropriate agencies. The
warnings should be delivered in a manner that will prompt appropriate action by
the population. In the film we saw that there was massive panic due to
uncertainty and sudden quarantine of large areas. If communication was done
more clearly from the CDC and government agencies to the people, then such
reactions might not have occurred and the infection could have been controlled
in a more organized manner.
I liked your emphasis on the many different aspects to addressing an outbreak. I agree that that was a major part of why the film was so scary. The social media aspect is also a relatively new factor to include in outbreak responses and I'm glad you mentioned it. I like that you go through the steps that the CDC took in the film after learning of the outbreak. Your point about the lack of communication is good too. One question I might ask is whether you think the lack of communication was due to overall poor communications systems or because the government tried to be secretive about the disease to prevent panic.
ReplyDeleteHi Yarelix,
ReplyDeleteExcellent blog this week. You summarized the film well. You also explained the various concepts mentioned in question 2, and related them to the movie. Be sure to review the Infectious Disease lecture slides from class to solidify these concepts. Regarding question 3, I agree with you that the movie showed a poor example of communication in a crisis. this certainly could have been better!
Erin